討論 - 防毒軟體評比報告 (02/26/2007)

[uplander]

防毒軟體的偵測率 (20070226):

‧AVIRA Premium Security Suite 7.0: 95.09% NEW
‧Fortinet FortiClient Host Security 3.0: 94.70%
‧BitDefender Internet Security v10: 92.36%
‧AOL Active Virus Shield (免費版本): 89.02%
‧AVIRA AntiVir PersonalEdition Classic 7.0 (免費版本): 88.44%
‧GRISOFT AVG Internet Security 7.5: 88.37%
‧Norman Virus Control Plus 5.82: 86.64% NEW
‧BitDefender 8 Free Edition (免費版本): 86.52%
‧Rising Antivirus 2007: 84.78%
‧Kaspersky Internet Security 6.0: 84.77%
‧Panda Internet Security 2007: 79.16%
‧MicroWorld eScan Internet Security 8.0: 77.68%
‧ClamWin Free Antivirus 0.90 (免費版本): 76.57%
‧Sunbelt CounterSpy V2: 76.39%
‧ALWIL avast Professional 4.7: 73.41%
‧F-Prot Antivirus 3.16f: 72.75%
‧Filseclab Twister Anti-TrojanVirus V7: 62.66%
‧Trend Micro Internet Security 2007: 60.53%
‧CA Internet Security 2007: 58.61%
‧AhnLab V3 Internet Security 2007 Platinum: 56.44%
‧Kingsoft Internet Security 2007: 55.55%
‧ESET NOD32 2.7: 49.17%
‧Jiangmin Antivirus KV 2007: 45.16%
‧Webroot Spy Sweeper with Antivirus: 40.71%
‧CAT Quick Heal Total Security 2006: 37.29%
‧Hauri Virobot Desktop 5.0: 34.38%
‧Microsoft Windows Live OneCare 1.5: 12.68% NEW
‧Comodo Antivirus 1.1 (免費版本): 9.92%

注意：
在這次的測試中，某些防毒軟體會� 成下面的問題：

1. 下面的防毒軟體會使得系統出現藍色死亡畫面(bugcheck 0x7f), 我們已經收集到系統所產生的memory dump：

‧F-Secure Internet Security 2007

2. 下列的防毒軟體會出現應用程式例外處理畫面：

‧Dr.Web Antivirus 4.33
‧Symantec Internet Security 2007
‧Virus Chaser Professional
‧VirusBuster Professional 2006
‧PC Tools Antivirus 3.1 (Free)
‧F-Prot Antivirus 3.16f

3. 當執行掃瞄病毒時，下列防毒軟體本身的執行程序會發生凍結現象：

‧Sunbelt CounterSpy V2

4. 下列的防毒軟體花費大量的掃瞄時間：

‧Sunbelt CounterSpy V2

5. 下列防毒軟體產生安裝錯誤 (利用 Windows Live OneCare Cleanup Tool 可以解決此問題)：

‧Microsoft Windows Live OneCare 1.5

6. 下列的防毒軟體花費大量的掃瞄時間：

‧Trend Micro Internet Security 2007 (over 40 hours)
‧AVIRA AntiVir PersonalEdition Classic 7.0 (Free) (over 64 hours)
‧AVIRA Premium Security Suite 7.0 (over 175 hours)
‧GRISOFT AVG Internet Security 7.5 (over 70 hours)

7. 授權碼過期 (不曉得有人有人可以提供授權碼給我們嗎？)：

‧McAfee Internet Security 2007


來源：
http://malware-test.com/smf/index.ph...e&topic=3716.0